Gym ProductReview

Home / Rankings / Creatine

Ranking

Best Creatine

Creatine comparison, rated and ranked on cost math, dose auditing, label disclosure and buyer ratings. 63 verified products today (what “verified” means).

Rule 1 Proteins R1 Creatine ranks first here (9.97 of 10) and has the lowest cost of the 58 of 63 ranked products whose cost per g creatine could be worked out from a current brand-store price: $0.018 per g creatine.

Ranking

  1. 1 RULE 1 PROTEINS R1 Creatine 9.97 composite $0.018per g creatine Find on Amazon: Rule 1 Proteins R1 Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
  2. 2 BULKSUPPLEMENTS Creatine Monohydrate 9.87 composite $0.025per g creatine Find on Amazon: BulkSupplements Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link
  3. 3 HORBAACH Creatine Monohydrate 2.2lb Powder 9.81 composite $0.027per g creatine Find on Amazon: Horbaach Creatine Monohydrate 2.2lb Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link
Filter 32 brands · formula

Pick up to four rows, then read them side by side.

Why a higher composite can sit lower: this table lists first the products scored on every component a label and a price can answer for, then those scored on at least 60% of that weighting, each group in composite order. So a product missing one of those components is placed after every product that has them all, even when its composite is higher, as 3 rows here are. How we rate gives the reason.

1
R1 Creatine
Find on Amazon: Rule 1 Proteins R1 Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
9.97 100% 10.0 10.0 $0.018
2
Creatine Monohydrate
Find on Amazon: BulkSupplements Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link
9.87 100% 10.0 9.8 $0.025
3 Find on Amazon: Horbaach Creatine Monohydrate 2.2lb Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.81 85% 10.0 9.7 $0.027
4
Creatine Monohydrate Powder
Find on Amazon: Huge Supplements Creatine Monohydrate Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link
9.70 100% 10.0 9.5 $0.037
5 Find on Amazon: Naked Nutrition Creatine Monohydrate Powder 500g (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.66 100% 10.0 9.3 $0.044
6 Find on Amazon: Orgain Creatine Monohydrate Micronized Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.47 100% 10.0 8.9 $0.046
7 Find on Amazon: Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Powder Unflavored (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.45 100% 10.0 9.1 $0.045
8 Find on Amazon: Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate Powder 500 Grams (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.40 100% 10.0 8.8 $0.047
9
Animal Micronized Creatine Powder Supplement
Find on Amazon: Animal Micronized Creatine Powder Supplement (opens in a new tab) paid link
9.26 100% 10.0 8.4 $0.051
10 Find on Amazon: Kaged Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.26 85% 10.0 8.6 $0.049
11 Find on Amazon: Cellucor Creatine Monohydrate Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.15 100% 10.0 8.3 $0.053
12
Creatine Powder
Find on Amazon: Double Wood Supplements Creatine Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link
9.07 100% 10.0 8.1 $0.056
13 Find on Amazon: NutraBio Creatine Monohydrate Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 9.02 100% 10.0 7.9 $0.058
14 View on Amazon: RYSE Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 8.94 100% 10.0 7.7 $0.060
15
Creatine
Find on Amazon: Promix Nutrition Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.87 100% 10.0 7.5 $0.066
16
Creatine5000 Powder
Find on Amazon: EVL Nutrition Creatine5000 Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.73 100% 10.0 7.4 $0.066
17
Orange Creatine
Find on Amazon: BulkSupplements Orange Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.69 100% 10.0 7.2 $0.068
18 Find on Amazon: Cellucor Jolly Rancher Flavored Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 8.44 100% 10.0 6.7 $0.072
19 Find on Amazon: BSN Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link 8.42 85% 10.0 7.0 $0.068
20 Find on Amazon: 1st Phorm Micronized Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 8.39 100% 10.0 6.5 $0.080
21
Creatine
Find on Amazon: Gorilla Mind Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.36 100% 10.0 6.5 $0.080
22
Jocko Creatine
Find on Amazon: Jocko Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.18 100% 10.0 6.0 $0.089
23
Trucreatine
View on Amazon: PEScience Trucreatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.16 100% 10.0 6.0 $0.089
24
Creatine
View on Amazon: Redcon1 Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
8.02 100% 10.0 5.6 $0.090
25
Creatine Pills
Find on Amazon: BulkSupplements Creatine Pills (opens in a new tab) paid link
7.80 100% 10.0 5.3 $0.093
26 Find on Amazon: Momentous Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 7.73 100% 10.0 5.1 $0.096
27 Find on Amazon: Optimum Nutrition Creatine Plus Micronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 7.69 100% 6.3 6.8 $0.071
28
Vital Proteins Creatine
Find on Amazon: Vital Proteins Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
7.59 85% 10.0 5.4 $0.092
29
Creatine
Find on Amazon: MusclePharm Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
7.55 100% 10.0 4.6 $0.100
30
Creatine
Find on Amazon: Ascent Protein Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
7.23 100% 10.0 4.0 $0.111
31 Find on Amazon: Naked Nutrition Lemon Lime Creatine Monohydrate Powder 1000g (opens in a new tab) paid link 7.21 100% 10.0 3.9 $0.120
32 Find on Amazon: Ghost Creatine Unflavored (opens in a new tab) paid link 7.12 85% 10.0 4.6 $0.100
33 Find on Amazon: Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate 750mg 500 Capsules (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.78 100% 6.0 4.9 $0.099
34 Find on Amazon: Ghost Creatine Strawbango (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.65 85% 10.0 3.7 $0.125
35 Find on Amazon: Ghost Creatine x Sour Strips Appleberry (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.65 85% 10.0 3.7 $0.125
36 Find on Amazon: Ghost Creatine x Warheads Sour Watermelon (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.65 85% 10.0 3.7 $0.125
37 Find on Amazon: Ghost Creatine x Welch's Grape (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.65 85% 10.0 3.7 $0.125
38
Creatine
Find on Amazon: Alani Nu Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link
6.39 100% 10.0 2.1 $0.167
39 Find on Amazon: Horbaach German Creatine Monohydrate 5000mg Per Serving 250 Capsules (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.28 85% 10.0 3.0 $0.127
40 View on Amazon: RYSE Loaded Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.10 100% 9.8 1.6 $0.281
41
Animal Creatine HMB Powder Supplement
Find on Amazon: Animal Creatine HMB Powder Supplement (opens in a new tab) paid link
5.81 100% 9.3 1.1 $0.333
42 Find on Amazon: Gorilla Mind Creatine Gummies (opens in a new tab) paid link 5.75 100% 10.0 0.9 $0.333
43
Creatine Capsules
Find on Amazon: Naked Nutrition Creatine Capsules (opens in a new tab) paid link
5.73 100% 5.0 2.8 $0.133
44 Find on Amazon: Swanson Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link 5.64 100% 2.0 4.2 $0.108
45
Recharge Post Workout
Find on Amazon: Legion Athletics Recharge Post Workout (opens in a new tab) paid link
5.63 100% 9.2 0.9 $0.333
46
Creatine HMB
Find on Amazon: Transparent Labs Creatine HMB (opens in a new tab) paid link
5.56 100% 7.5 1.4 $0.300
47 Find on Amazon: Jocko Fuel Pro Series Creatine (opens in a new tab) paid link 5.17 85% 10.0 0.9 $0.333
48 Find on Amazon: Nutricost Creatine Energy Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 5.04 85% 5.9 2.5 $0.147
49
Creatine HCL
Find on Amazon: Gorilla Mind Creatine HCL (opens in a new tab) paid link
4.46 85% 5.0 1.8 $0.200
50
Creatine Energy
Find on Amazon: EVL Nutrition Creatine Energy (opens in a new tab) paid link
4.21 100% 2.4 2.3 $0.147
51 Find on Amazon: Naked Nutrition Raspberry Lime Creatine HCL Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 3.77 100% 1.5 0.0 $0.687
52
Creatine Monohydrate
Find on Amazon: Double Wood Supplements Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link
3.47 85% 2.0 1.2 $0.333
53 Find on Amazon: Kaged Creatine HCL (opens in a new tab) paid link 2.89 85% 1.5 0.3 $0.355
54
Creatine L-Arginine
Find on Amazon: EVL Nutrition Creatine L-Arginine (opens in a new tab) paid link
2.68 85% 1.0 0.2 $0.500
55 Find on Amazon: Nutricost Creatine Aminos Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 1.94 85% 1.3 2.6 $0.140
56 Find on Amazon: Nutricost Creatine for Women (opens in a new tab) paid link 6.78 80% not enough data 4.7 $0.100
57 Find on Amazon: Orgain Creatine Lean Muscle Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link 5.79 65% not enough data 6.1 $0.088
58
Creatine Chewable Tablets Supplement
Find on Amazon: Animal (Universal Nutrition) Creatine Chewable Tablets Supplement (opens in a new tab) paid link
5.39 80% not enough data 1.9 $0.200
59 Find on Amazon: Cellucor Cor Performance Creatine Flavored (opens in a new tab) paid link not enough data 55% 10.0 not enough data not enough data
60 Find on Amazon: Dymatize Creatine Monohydrate (opens in a new tab) paid link not enough data 55% 10.0 not enough data not enough data
61
Creatine Chew Tabs
Find on Amazon: EVL Nutrition Creatine Chew Tabs (opens in a new tab) paid link
not enough data 40% 6.0 not enough data not enough data
62
Creatine Gummies Supplement
Find on Amazon: Double Wood Supplements Creatine Gummies Supplement (opens in a new tab) paid link
not enough data 40% 2.0 not enough data not enough data
63 Find on Amazon: BulkSupplements Creatine Ethyl Ester HCL Cee Powder (opens in a new tab) paid link not enough data 15% not enough data not enough data not enough data

Click a column header to sort. not enough data means the number could not be verified from the label or price on record — never estimated.

What the labels state

Across the 63 products in this category whose labels two independent readers transcribed: how many list each audited ingredient, how many print an amount for it, and how many print at least the reference amount the dose audit compares it with. 4 of the 63 published carry a proprietary blend: one total amount for a group of ingredients, with no amount for each.

IngredientLabels listing itAmount printedReference amountAt or above it
Creatine Monohydrate59595,000 mg50

Ingredients listed on at least 5 labels. Each ingredient’s page names every product counted here, its amount, and the published source of the reference amount. The creatine monohydrate vs creatine HCl guide sets the shelf’s two forms side by side.

How this ranking is built

ComponentWeightBasis
Value45%Cost per gram of creatine, ranked against the category — not per gram of everything else in the tub, so a creatine sold with HMB or betaine answers on the creatine you are actually buying
Dose integrity20%Each audited active’s disclosed dose as a share of its reference dose (capped at the reference dose), averaged and put on a 10-point scale, minus 2 points for a proprietary blend
Label disclosure20%Share of the actives the label puts a number against. An amount hidden in a proprietary blend, or simply not stated, scores zero here rather than counting as missing data — non-disclosure is a fact about a label, not an absence of one
Consensus15%Buyer rating shown on the brand’s own product page (read from the page, or from the review service that draws its stars; source-linked), minimum 25 reviews, re-read within the last 30 days, count, source and capture date printed on every product page

A missing component is never scored as zero. Its weight is redistributed across the components that exist, and the page says which one was omitted.

On a budget: Best Cheap & Budget Creatine, the 29 products at or below the median cost per gram of creatine, ranked by the same composite.

Tool: creatine price comparison: cost per gram, every product cheapest first.

Data study: What 63 creatine labels say and what a gram of creatine costs, with the spread of cost per gram of creatine across this shelf, how it changes with size, creatine per serving, the form each label names, and a CSV. All data studies.