Gym ProductReview

Independent supplement ratings

Gym Products Scored on Published Arithmetic

Every score worked out on its category’s published weighting — cost per unit of the active, the label’s doses and disclosure, sourced buyer ratings. Weighted, capped, and never moved by an affiliate link.

Browse the rankings How we rate

Every score we publish 534 scored
0510
50brands tracked
686panels read from brand labels and tables
27cited reference doses
669verified products

Latest price, rating or label read: November 20, 2026 · A published weighting for every category.

Verified: two independent readers agreed on the label, or the figures were parsed from the brand’s own machine-readable nutrition table (how we rate).

Prices are re-read daily from brands’ own stores, never from Amazon, and the changes are recorded: price drops at brand stores.

Browse the rankings

All rankings →
92 ranked · 78 scored Protein Powders 1BulkSupplements Soy Protein Isolate Powder9.82 2Naked Nutrition Pea Protein Powder9.55 3BulkSupplements Casein Protein Powder9.31 Full ranking → 64 ranked · 53 scored Protein Bars 1Pure Protein Chocolate Deluxe Protein Bar7.23 2Clif Builders Chocolate7.00 3Clif Builders Cookies Cream7.00 Full ranking → 75 ranked · 62 scored Protein Snacks 1Quest Nutrition Vanilla Protein Shakes8.82 2Quest Nutrition Coffee Protein Shake8.77 3Quest Nutrition Salted Caramel Protein Shakes8.77 Full ranking → 63 ranked · 59 scored Pre-Workouts 1NutraBio Base Pre Workout9.50 2Huge Supplements Wrecked Pre Workout9.36 3PEScience Prolific 1 Complete Pre Workout9.06 Full ranking → 50 ranked · 35 scored Energy Drinks 1Cellucor C4 Energy Amino9.67 2Cellucor C4 Energy Aminos Jolly Rancher9.67 3Cellucor C4 Energy Aminos Popsicle9.67 Full ranking → 63 ranked · 58 scored Creatine 1Rule 1 Proteins R1 Creatine9.97 2BulkSupplements Creatine Monohydrate9.87 3Horbaach Creatine Monohydrate 2.2lb Powder9.81 Full ranking → 49 ranked · 38 scored Collagen 1BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Bovine Collagen Powder9.91 2BulkSupplements Hydrolyzed Collagen Porcine Powder9.79 3Horbaach Collagen Peptides 40oz Powder9.78 Full ranking → 48 ranked · 22 scored Caffeine, Green Tea, Carnitine & Fiber 1NutraBio Caffeine 200mg9.66 2Nutricost Natural Caffeine Capsules 200mg 250 Capsules9.56 3EVL Nutrition Caffeine Tablets8.45 Full ranking → 59 ranked · 41 scored Vitamin D, Omega-3, NAC & Milk Thistle 1Horbaach Vitamin D 3 1000iu10.00 2Swanson Vitamin D 3 5000 IU9.86 3BulkSupplements Vitamin D3 Softgels9.81 Full ranking → 49 ranked · 47 scored Electrolytes 11st Phorm Hydration Sport9.39 2Skratch Labs Unsweetened Hydration Sport Drink Mix8.95 3Jocko Fuel Rapid Hydration8.41 Full ranking → 47 ranked · 41 scored BCAA & EAA 1BulkSupplements BCAA 2:1:1 Branched Chain Amino Acids Powder9.93 2Nutricost BCAA Powder9.53 3Kaged BCAA 2:1:19.16 Full ranking →

The two numbers

Both are computed from a product's own label and its current price. Neither is a matter of taste, and both can be recalculated by anyone who wants to check.

  1. 01

    Cost per gram of protein

    Price divided by the protein in the package. A tub that looks cheap on the shelf is often expensive per gram, and the ranking that matters is rarely the one on the price tag.

  2. 02

    Dose auditing

    Each active that has a cited threshold is measured against a reference dose — 27 thresholds, each printed with its type (the dose a trial gave, one end of a position-stand range, or an intake guideline), its citation and its evidence grade. A “6 g performance blend” cannot hold the 8 g of citrulline malate the cited trial used, and the blend hides how much it does hold.

  3. 03

    If the readers disagree, it doesn’t publish

    Most panels are read from the label image by two independent readers. If their readings disagree on a single value, the product is held back until a third independent reading agrees with one of them — never published with a number we are unsure of. Where a brand publishes its panel as machine-readable data, that is parsed instead, and the product page says so.

Illustration: a supplement tub, a scoop of powder on a weighing scale, a magnifying glass and a ruler
Fig. 1 — The audit, in practice: the label, the scale, and the arithmetic between them.

Why proprietary blends get penalised

A blend lists its ingredients but not their individual doses. That is legal, common, and makes the formula unauditable: a label can print citrulline, beta-alanine and caffeine inside a 750 mg blend when the reference dose of citrulline alone is 6,000 mg.

Since a blend hides whether the dose is real, an ingredient inside one is scored as undosed rather than assumed adequate, and the product carries an explicit penalty. If a brand discloses its doses, that shows up in its score.

What is published, and what is not

The rated products are live. Most had their supplement facts panel read from the label image by two independent readers, and only products with two independent readings that agreed on every value were published. Where the first two readings disagreed — even on a single ingredient — the product was held back until a third independent reading agreed with one of them, rather than published with a number we are unsure of. The rest were parsed from a brand’s own machine-readable nutrition data; every product page names the extraction path it came from.

Where a brand publishes its panel as machine-readable text, a single structured read suffices and the record says so. An image-only panel whose readings disagree waits for a third independent reading before it can appear.

Aggregated buyer sentiment is live where it can be sourced: the rating a brand publishes on its own product page, counted and linked at every use, and scored only when at least 25 reviews stand behind it. Where no machine-readable rating exists, the component is omitted and the page says so — never a number invented to fill a column.

On affiliate links. Some links on this site earn a commission, and every page carrying one says so. No brand pays for a rating, and no rating changes because a brand enrolled. Any product can be rated whether or not there is money in it.

Read how the ratings are calculated for the full method, including the dose thresholds and their sources.

Every number on this site traces to a source you can open.

See the rankings Read the method