Home / Field guides / Reference Doses: What the Research Actually Used
Field guide
Reference Doses: What the Research Actually Used
Every ingredient on a supplement label is a dose decision, and most labels don't tell you what that decision was measured against. Below are the thresholds behind the pre-workout ratings, drawn from the trials and position stands cited beside them, along with what the research actually looked like and why "more" isn't automatically "better."
The thresholds
These ten are among the actives a pre-workout is audited on; a pre-workout is also measured against any other threshold that is not limited to another shelf. The full set — every threshold used anywhere on the site, and every ingredient that is recognised but deliberately left unscored because no research establishes a dose for it — is published on how we rate.
| Ingredient | Reference dose | Type | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| L-Citrulline | 6,000 mg | trial dose | Bailey et al., J Appl Physiol 2015 |
| Citrulline Malate 2:1 | 8,000 mg | trial dose | Pérez-Guisado & Jakeman, J Strength Cond Res 2010 |
| Beta-Alanine | 4,000 mg | position-stand range | Trexler et al., ISSN Position Stand 2015 (low end of 4-6 g) |
| Creatine Monohydrate | 5,000 mg | position-stand range | Kreider et al., ISSN Position Stand 2017 |
| Betaine Anhydrous | 2,500 mg | trial dose | Cholewa et al., J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2013 |
| Caffeine | 200 mg | position-stand range | Guest et al., ISSN Position Stand 2021 |
| L-Tyrosine | 2,000 mg | trial dose | Colzato et al., Front Behav Neurosci 2013 |
| Taurine | 1,000 mg | trial dose | Balshaw et al., Amino Acids 2013 |
| Alpha-GPC | 250 mg | trial dose | Marcus et al., J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2017 (lower of two doses) |
| L-Theanine | 100 mg | trial dose | Owen et al., Nutr Neurosci 2008 (100 mg together with 50 mg caffeine) |
These are numbers a pre-workout is scored against, and each is a reference dose of the type shown beside it. Not a marketing claim: a trial dose is the dose the cited trial gave; a position-stand range is one end of the range the cited position stand states (the low end for beta-alanine, the high end for creatine). Elsewhere on the site there is a third type, an intake guideline: a population intake a guideline body sets for healthy adults, such as the vitamin D3 RDA or the EPA + DHA adequate intake, which is not a dose a trial gave. One is not exactly a figure its source prints: caffeine's 200 mg is derived from a per-kilogram range (see below). L-theanine's trial gave it only together with caffeine. Its threshold earlier cited Giesbrecht et al. (2010), which gave 97 mg with 40 mg caffeine.
A threshold is only applied where the research that produced it was measured. Some are scoped to a single shelf for that reason: leucine's range is stated for an acute protein dose alongside a balanced array of the essential amino acids, so it is audited on the amino rankings rather than against a pre-workout that happens to contain leucine. Citing a trial at a product it was not measured on would be a wrong number wearing a citation.
Citrulline malate and L-citrulline are not the same ingredient
This is the single most common source of confusion on a pre-workout label, and it's worth being precise about it.
L-citrulline is the free amino acid on its own. Citrulline malate is L-citrulline bound to malate, typically in a 2:1 ratio, meaning a given weight of citrulline malate contains meaningfully less actual citrulline than the same weight of pure L-citrulline — the malate portion adds mass without adding citrulline.
Bailey et al. (2015) gave 6 g of L-citrulline a day for 7 days. Pérez-Guisado & Jakeman (2010) gave a single 8 g dose of citrulline malate. Those are different compounds studied at different total weights, and treating "8 g citrulline malate" as equivalent to or better than "6 g L-citrulline" misreads the label. A product listing "citrulline malate 8,000 mg" is not delivering 8 g of citrulline — depending on the exact ratio used, the actual citrulline content is lower: about 5.3 g if the 2:1 is by weight, about 5.8 g if it is two molecules of citrulline per molecule of malic acid (our arithmetic from the molecular weights, 175.19 and 134.09) — and it isn't automatically equivalent to a product listing "L-citrulline 6,000 mg," which delivers a full 6 g of the amino acid itself.
This is why the two are tracked as separate line items rather than folded into one "citrulline" bucket. Conflating them would mean crediting a product for a dose it didn't actually deliver, which defeats the purpose of dose auditing in the first place.
Why exceeding a dose isn't a bonus
It's intuitive to assume that if 4,000 mg of beta-alanine is the low end of the studied range, then 8,000 mg must deserve more credit. That isn't how we score.
The reference dose is the figure its source states: for the trial doses among these ten, the amount the cited trial gave; for beta-alanine and creatine, the end of the range the cited position stand states; for caffeine, a figure derived from the low end of its position stand's per-kilogram range (see below). A label is credited in proportion up to it — half the dose earns half the credit — and not past it: it is not a point on a scale where more is proportionally better. The research measured what it measured at the doses it used, and going past them means you're outside the figures a "clinical dose" claim on a label borrows its credibility from. A product that doses far above the threshold hasn't shown anything more on its label than one that meets it. That is why this site credits a dose up to the threshold and no further.
Practically, this also means a giant dose isn't a substitute for an honest label. A product could bury an ingredient at 20,000 mg specifically to make the "clinically dosed" claim viscerally impressive while the total serving becomes unpalatable, expensive, or oddly proportioned relative to everything else in the formula. Meeting the threshold is the bar. It isn't a race past it.
What this means for reading a label
The useful exercise is narrow: find the ingredient, find its disclosed dose, and compare it against the number the research actually used — not a rounder number, not a related-sounding compound, not an assumption based on where it sits in the ingredient list. Where a dose isn't disclosed at all, because it sits inside a proprietary blend, there's no way to run this comparison, which is exactly why blends carry their own separate scrutiny.
This isn't dosing advice — what to take, and how much, is a decision between a reader and whoever they get personal guidance from. It's a description of what a specific set of studies used, so a label claim can be checked against something real.
Why these particular studies
The sources above aren't an arbitrary pick from the literature. Several are ISSN (International Society of Sports Nutrition) Position Stands — consensus documents where a panel of researchers reviews the available trials on an ingredient and states the doses those trials used. Where a single trial is cited instead of a position stand, the threshold is a dose that trial gave to healthy adults; how each figure was taken from its source is written beside it on how we rate. None of this makes the number permanent — sports nutrition research continues, and a threshold can move if better evidence arrives — but it does mean each figure traces back to a published, citable source rather than to convention or round numbers that simply sound sufficient.
A caffeine range worth noting
Caffeine is the one ingredient on this list most often dosed by body weight in the underlying research rather than as a single fixed number — Guest et al. describe research doses of around 3–6 mg per kilogram of body weight, and 200 mg is used here as a fixed floor because a label states milligrams, not milligrams per kilogram. 3 mg/kg for a 67 kg adult is 201 mg, which the threshold rounds to 200 mg, so whether a given figure sits inside 3–6 mg/kg depends on body weight, which a label cannot know. A product listing less than 200 mg is credited in proportion; a product listing more is credited no further than 200 mg, whether or not the extra would still sit inside 3–6 mg/kg for a particular reader.
Only caffeine the label states is counted. A caffeine salt or complex — di-caffeine malate, zumXR and the like — weighs more than the caffeine in it: a label that does the arithmetic prints, for example, 133 mg of di-caffeine malate yielding 100 mg of caffeine. So such a row counts at the caffeine yield its label states, and a row that states no yield is shown on the product page as caffeine not stated and adds nothing; the caffeine anhydrous or other plain caffeine on the same label still counts in full.